Disclosure: As a BetterHelp affiliate, we receive compensation from BetterHelp if you purchase products or services through the links provided.
For those suffering from addiction, staying in recovery can seem like a constant struggle even during periods when their lives appear stable and positive.
On the surface, it may not make sense that addicts would choose to relapse just when things are going well.
However, there are complex psychological factors at play that can actually increase vulnerability to returning to old habits when life circumstances improve.
Understanding why periods of success can paradoxically heighten relapse risk is an important part of long-term recovery.
In this article, we aim to explore this seeming contradiction, exploring the psychological and external factors that contribute to relapse during times of apparent well-being.
By peeling back the layers of this complex dynamic, we seek to provide insights and strategies that empower individuals in their pursuit of sustained recovery.
The Nature of Addiction
Addiction is a complex and chronic condition that fundamentally alters brain function, making it more than just a behavioral issue.
At its core, addiction is characterized by a compulsive need to seek and use substances despite adverse consequences.
This persistent and relapsing nature distinguishes addiction from other health conditions.
It goes beyond occasional misuse and becomes a formidable challenge to sustained recovery.
The brain’s reward system plays a pivotal role in addiction, with substances triggering the release of neurotransmitters like dopamine that create feelings of pleasure and reinforcement.
Over time, repeated substance use leads to changes in the brain’s structure and function, fostering a heightened sensitivity to the substance and diminishing the ability to experience pleasure from other natural rewards.
In exploring why addicts may relapse during periods of stability, it is important to recognize addiction as a persistent challenge that demands ongoing attention and management.
Common Relapse Triggers
Many triggers, both internal and external, play a key role in influencing an individual’s vulnerability to returning to substance use.
These triggers may include the following:
1. Emotional Relapse Triggers
Intense positive emotions like joy, excitement, and celebratory feelings can sometimes mask deeper unresolved emotional pain from the past.
This can trigger addicts to use drugs/alcohol to augment positive emotions or numb negative feelings.
Relapse may occur due to the inability to process intense emotions in a healthy way.
2. Interpersonal Triggers
Conflicts or tensions in important personal relationships, whether romantic partnerships, family dynamics, or friendships, are also major risk factors.
Unresolved resentments, abandonment fears, or damaged trust from active addiction can resurface during arguments and lead to using it as an escape.
3. Boredom and Idleness
Having free time on their hands without productive activities or distractions increases restlessness and dwells on cravings for many recovering addicts.
Without a daily schedule and purposeful routine, idle time raises the risk of returning to old coping behaviors.
4. Stress and Negative Moods
Feelings of stress, irritability, frustration, or anxiety are still common even during successful periods.
If recovering individuals haven’t learned new stress management skills, they may impulsively turn back to addictive substances for temporary relief from unpleasant moods and tensions.
5. Location Triggers
Revisiting settings strongly linked to past drug use, such as favorite bars, a former dealer’s house, or hangouts with using friends, places the individual in a high-risk situation surrounded by cues for addiction behavior.
Why Do Addicts Relapse When Things Are Good?
The paradox of addiction recovery often surfaces when individuals find themselves succumbing to the allure of substance use, even when life appears to be on an upswing.
Several complex factors contribute to this phenomenon:
1. Complacency and Overconfidence:
Exiting an inpatient program or reaching a period of stability can sometimes instill a false sense of confidence.
Overconfident individuals may believe they have conquered their addiction entirely and, as a result, may become lax in attending meetings or engaging with their support community.
This can diminish the vigilance required to combat triggers, increasing the risk of relapse.
2. Longing for Familiarity and Comfort:
Adjusting to a calm and stable lifestyle can be unexpectedly challenging for individuals accustomed to the chaos induced by substance abuse.
The absence of constant upheaval may create a sense of stagnation, prompting some to yearn for the excitement and adventure they associate with their previous life of substance abuse.
This nostalgia for the chaos can lead to romanticizing the past and, in turn, increase the risk of relapse.
3. Lack of Coping Mechanisms:
Some individuals may have developed coping mechanisms primarily tailored for challenging times.
When faced with positive life changes, the absence of effective coping strategies for managing joy, success, or contentment can leave individuals vulnerable to the temptation of reverting to substances.
4. Disconnection from Support Systems:
Positive phases may inadvertently lead to a disconnection from support systems, as individuals may feel less inclined to seek assistance when things are going well.
Isolation and a lack of accountability can diminish the protective factors that support networks provide during challenging times.
5. Associating Happiness with Substance Use:
For some, the association between happiness and substance use formed during periods of positive experiences can become deeply ingrained.
Breaking this association requires a conscious effort to redefine joy and contentment without the crutch of substances.
6. Trigger Minimization:
During periods of stability, addicts become lax about identifying and avoiding people, places, and things associated with their past drug use.
Triggers that they have worked hard to dodge start to seem less threatening, and they start to rationalize casual exposure rather than acknowledging it as high-risk.
Over time, this normalization erodes the coping skills developed during recovery, and the force of triggers reemerges subtly, often without individuals being fully aware of the shift.
7. Loss of Identity:
After identifying as “an addict” for a significant period, transitioning to a new identity devoid of substance use can be an unfamiliar and challenging process.
Despite achieving sobriety milestones, the absence of addiction as a core identity leaves a void.
Accomplishments in recovery may struggle to replace the familiar sense of self associated with addiction.
Without proper guidance, the task of forming a replacement identity seems daunting, and relapse offers instant relief in such a situation by reverting to comforting old patterns.
So in many cases, it’s actually when pressures seem lighter that an addict’s vulnerabilities and reluctance to fully address underlying issues can resurface and lead to lapsing behaviors.
Stages of Relapse
Relapse does not typically occur suddenly but follows the following series of stages that can unfold over time if the at-risk individual does not implement strategies to interrupt the process:
1. Emotional Relapse
This initial stage involves emotional signs, where individuals may not be consciously contemplating using substances, but emotions and behaviors set the stage for potential relapse.
Neglecting self-care, bottling up emotions, and isolating oneself are early warning signs that one may be heading toward a vulnerable state.
2. Mental Relapse
When emotional triggers are not managed, mental relapse progresses.
Individuals may find themselves oscillating between the desire to use substances and the commitment to remain sober.
Their mind may romanticize the perceived benefits of their past addiction or minimize the negatives.
Rationally, they understand the dangers but their cravings start to feel irresistible.
3. Behavioral Relapse
The final stage manifests as behavioral relapse, where the actual return to substance use occurs.
Withdrawing from usual routines, making excuses to avoid responsibilities, or engaging with people/places significantly tied to using substances are red flags that precede this stage.
More directly reckless behaviors around substances are observable, testing limits and chasing the same buzz as before.
Recognizing where one is at in the stages helps catch a relapse before it’s too late.
It allows one to identify the warning signs, intervene early, and implement effective coping mechanisms.
Dealing with Relapse
If relapse has already occurred, it is important not to discard all progress made in recovery thus far or view it as a complete failure.
Relapse is often a natural part of the recovery process for many and can provide valuable lessons if approached constructively.
The key is to not lose hope, and instead view it as an opportunity to deepen insight into personal relapse triggers and strengthen protective strategies.
The first priority should be to stop continuing drug use and isolate from people and places strongly associated with addiction.
Taking a personal inventory to honestly reflect on what life circumstances and thoughts preceded the lapse can help surface vulnerable areas to target.
Additional treatment or adjusting an existing recovery plan may be needed with guidance from clinical experts to heal underlying issues that may have led to the relapse.
Returning to recovery fundamentals like exercising, meditating, journaling, and calling on crisis plans helps stabilize and quiet cravings during this sensitive time.
It is crucial not to descend into shame-induced isolation which risks perpetuating the cycle of substance abuse.
With time and dedication to learning from mistakes, relapse sets the stage for stronger long-term recovery when used as a learning experience rather than a defeat.
How to Help a Loved One Who Relapsed?
Supporting a loved one in their journey through addiction recovery requires a delicate balance of empathy, understanding, and proactive assistance
Here are some suggestions for helping a loved one who has relapsed:
Express care, concern, and willingness to help rather than anger or disappointment over the relapse.
Avoid enabling behavior by setting clear boundaries. For example, do not provide money or shelter the person from the natural consequences of their use.
Have an open and honest discussion about treatment options. Respectfully encourage them to seek further professional support through detox, counseling, support groups, etc.
Help them avoid people, places, and things that trigger use. Offer social support by engaging in alternative activities together that don’t involve using.
Remind them of recovery progress made and strengths shown previously. Help maintain optimism that they can get sober again with proper support.
Be vigilant for any changes in mental health, physical symptoms, or behavioral signs that could indicate substance dependency or greater risk. Medical attention may be warranted.
Communicate regularly to monitor their wellbeing and check if cravings emerge, without enabling use. Check-ins help them feel accountable.
In conclusion, relapse is often a complicated process influenced by both internal and external factors.
While it may seem counterintuitive that addicts would return to substance use during positive times, the psychological vulnerabilities that drive addiction do not simply disappear even when life circumstances improve.
Issues like overconfidence, longing for familiarity, lack of coping mechanisms, and identity crisis can all contribute to relapse occurring during periods when an addict’s world seems stable.
With a deeper understanding of what prompts relapse, even in better times, recovering addicts are better equipped to maintain long-term sobriety by addressing their needs.
1. Can relapse occur even after years of sobriety?
Yes, relapse is a possibility at any stage of the recovery journey, even after years of sobriety. Factors such as life changes, stressors, and unresolved emotional issues can contribute to relapse.
2. How can family and friends support a loved one to prevent relapse?
Supporting a loved one in recovery involves fostering open communication, encouraging healthy habits, and actively participating in their support network. Understanding triggers and being vigilant during both challenging and positive phases is essential.
3. What role does professional help play in preventing relapse?
Seeking professional help, such as therapy and counseling, is crucial in addressing underlying issues, developing coping strategies, and ensuring ongoing support. Professional guidance enhances the effectiveness of relapse prevention plans.
4. Are there specific signs that indicate an increased risk of relapse?
Signs of an increased risk of relapse may include withdrawal from support networks, changes in behavior, neglecting self-care, and expressing a longing for past substance use.